Alice Waters is calling on the Organic Consumers Association (OCA) and activist John Stauber to issue a public apology and to “retract false statements” made by the OAC on the subject of sewage sludge. The OCA accused Ms Waters and the Chez Panisse Foundation of acting hypocritically.

As we reported yesterday, the OCA plans to picket outside Chez Panisse today at noon to raise awareness of what it sees as a contradiction: Francesca Vietor, a Commissioner on the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission which has in the past given away sewage sludge to be used as compost, is also the Executive Director of the Chez Panisse Foundation which does not use the sludge on its related gardens.

The Chez Panisse Foundation issued the following statement this morning:

Statement from the Chez Panisse Foundation

On March 29, 2010, at the request of activist John Stauber and the Organic Consumers Association.
Alice Waters issued a statement calling for safe composting methods in San Francisco.Representatives from the OCA responded by shamelessly misrepresenting her position, repeating false accusations against Francesca Vietor, the Executive Director of the Chez Panisse Foundation and Commissioner on the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, and announcing a plan to picket Chez Panisse Restaurant. The Chez Panisse Foundation welcomes a full public airing of the facts of the situation, which follow. In particular, the Chez Panisse Foundation has learned that the Center for Food Safety, which filed the original petition on this matter to the Public Utilities Commission last year, is not a party to OCA’s planned demonstration at the Chez Panisse Restaurant.

The Organic Consumers Association claims to be “leading a campaign to stop the SFPUC from giving away sewage sludge.” But the truth is, the SFPUC has already stopped, directly because of the intervention of Ms. Vietor. Mr. Stauber and the OCA have also repeatedly charged that Ms. Vietor has been “actively promoting sewage sludge.” This is entirely false, as Mr. Stauber has been informed more than once. Ms. Vietor has never promoted the SFPUC program. In fact, as soon as Mr. Stauber brought the program to her attention, Ms. Vietor asked the staff of the SFPUC to do three things:

Put the program on indefinite hold until sound scientific data can be gathered and evaluated;
Conduct additional, rigorous testing of the material the PUC had been giving away; and
Issue a public call for solutions to the larger question of how San Francisco and municipalities
everywhere should be dealing with their waste.

As part of the SFPUC’s re-evaluation efforts, SFPUC staff requested that the OCA share the scientific data that, according to the OCA, proves unsafe practices. In a letter dated March 26, 2010, the OCA refused to share its data.

Alice Waters believes deeply in organic farming and gardening. Her forty years of advocacy on this issue speak for themselves. She and the Chez Panisse Foundation believe that rigorous science, transparently evaluated, should be the basis of government policy.

The Foundation looks forward to ensuring public review of the science on this matter and working with the SFPUC and other relevant stakeholders to insure that safe practices are followed, here in the Bay Area and beyond.

But we have no confidence, in view of their actions, that Mr. Stauber or the OCA share these goals. By refusing to acknowledge and correct their false accusations, Mr. Stauber and the OCA have attempted to taint the reputations of Alice Waters and Francesca Vietor, both of whom have long and outstanding records as environmental advocates. The Chez Panisse Foundation calls on Mr. Stauber and the OCA to retract their false statements and issue Alice Waters and Francesca Vietor a public apology.

Tracey Taylor

Tracey Taylor is co-founder of Berkeleyside and co-founder and editorial director of Cityside, the nonprofit parent to Berkeleyside and The Oaklandside. Before launching Berkeleyside, Tracey wrote for...

Join the Conversation


  1. People need to understand that OCA et al = scurrilous, lowlifes: Ronnie Cummins, yes OCA members, he is running a game on you, he’s got about as much integrity as the wizard behind the curtain; John Stauber, what the freak did his parents do to him, he’s so insecure he doesn’t even trust his own reflection in a mirror, that man’s sense of morality is shattered; and Hugh Kaufman. Yo, Hugh, they say it’s been years since the EPA took away your bully pulpit but you’re still referring to yourself as a sr. policy analyst. Get with it and go somewhere and take your meds and a nap. What a bunch of freaking losers!!! Alice Waters please take the issue of sewage sludge away from these parasites. We have no need of them in SF.

  2. This is typical of the OCA’s tactics – misrepresent facts to attack those who they should be applauding. I haven’t figured out why, except maybe a perverse desire to portray themselves as the true radical heroes. I doubt if they would ever apologize for anything, but nice try. Alice has my complete support and sympathy.